Opinion: Replacing human relationships with chatbots is inherently harmful
Although roughly half of Americans report having fewer than three friends and also say they experience loneliness, filling the companionship gap with AI chatbot friends and romantic partners is not a good solution, according to a Nov. 16 opinion piece in First Things co-authored by Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health’s Tyler VanderWeele. The authors call for bans on the technology, arguing that these chatbots are inherently harmful because they undermine people’s capacity to form and sustain real relationships.
VanderWeele, John L. Loeb and Frances Lehman Loeb Professor of Epidemiology and director of the Human Flourishing Program, and co-author Jonathan Teubner, research associate in the Human Flourishing Program, note that use of companion chatbots may increase social isolation, which is particularly concerning given that nearly 75% of American teenagers have tried an AI companion.
Research from the Global Flourishing Study, which VanderWeele co-directs, has documented the important role of strong social relationships in well-being. Last year, the study reported that young people had the lowest levels of well-being of any age group.
While VanderWeele and Teubner see federal and state legislation barring minors from using companion chatbots as a positive step, they write that bans for all ages are warranted.
“We are made for one another, and learning to bear the friction of a relationship—to be known, to disappoint or be disappointed, to forgive or be forgiven—is not an obstacle to the good life but constitutive of it,” they write. “A truly flourishing society would not stop at protecting its children from these tools. It would ask the harder question: If these systems erode the capacities on which a flourishing life depends, why should harms to the young be the only ones that merit prevention?”
Read First Things opinion piece: Time to Ban AI Companions